Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce Alternatives: Perfect For Your Seafood Dish

Seafood dishes are a favorite in my house, but you don’t always have the time to make a cocktail sauce from scratch. Most store-bought cocktail sauces are full of sugar and other unhealthy ingredients. Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce alternatives are the perfect solution. 

These sauces are made with all-natural ingredients. They not only have a great taste, like the Trader Joe’s Cocktail sauce, but they are also healthy for you.

We have found great alternatives to the Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce that we think you will love. So, if you are looking for a healthier option for your seafood dish, be sure to check out these sauces.

Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce Comparison 2022

  • Best for bold and spicy flavors: [amazon link=”B001SB54JC” title=”Try Me Sauce Tiger” /]
  • Runner-up: [amazon link=”B00KOALYQK” title=”Louisiana Sauce Cocktail Horserdsh” /]
  • Best for a good texture : [amazon link=”B000CPIN98″ title=”Historic Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Jalapeno Seafood Cocktail Sauce” /]
  • Best for dressing up shrimp: [amazon link=”B00O86RXCA” title=”Sable & Rosenfeld Tipsy Cocktail Sauce” /]
  • Best for gluten-free: [amazon link=”B07XPD9B3D” title=”Heartbeat Hot Sauce – Milder Ones Collection” /]

[amazon bestseller=”Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce” items=”20″ ]

Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce Reviews 2022

Best For Bold And Spicy Flavors – Try Me Sauce Tiger

[amazon box=”B001SB54JC” ]

Looking for a condiment that will make your taste buds tingle? Then, you’ll want to try Try Me Sauce Tiger! This unique sauce is perfect for those who enjoy bold and spicy flavors. Made with a blend of chili peppers, vinegar, and spices, Try Me Sauce Tiger adds an extra zing to any dish.

Its texture is slightly thick, and its color is a bright red. The sauce has a strong vinegar smell with a hint of sweetness. Once you take a bite, you’ll first notice the heat from the peppers. 

But, this quickly fades into a more moderate spice level that lingers on your tongue. The vinegar flavor is also present, but it’s not overwhelming. And the sweetness from the sugar balances out the other flavors perfectly.

If you’re looking for a new condiment to spice up your meals, then you’ll want to give Try Me Sauce Tiger a try!

Pros:

  • Adds an extra zing to any dish
  • Bold and spicy flavors
  • Unique taste

Cons:

  • It may be too spicy for some

Runner-Up – Louisiana Sauce Cocktail Horseradish

[amazon box=”B00KOALYQK” ]

When it comes to seafood, there’s nothing quite like a good cocktail sauce to enhance the flavors. Louisiana Sauce Cocktail Horserdsh is a great option for those looking for an alternative to traditional cocktail sauce. This sauce is perfect for shrimp, crab, and other seafood dishes. 

It is made with a blend of horseradish, ketchup, and spices. This combination gives it a unique flavor that is perfect for those who enjoy a little bit of heat with their seafood. The sauce is also great for dipping and can be used as a condiment on sandwiches and burgers. 

So if you’re looking for a delicious and unique cocktail sauce alternative, be sure to check out Louisiana Sauce Cocktail Horserdsh. You won’t be disappointed.

Pros:

  • Unique flavor
  • Great for shrimp, crab, and other seafood dishes
  • Perfect for those who enjoy a little bit of heat
  • Also great for dipping and can be used as a condiment

Cons:

  • None

Best For A Good Texture – Historic Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Jalapeno Seafood Cocktail Sauce

[amazon box=”B000CPIN98″ ]

This Historic Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Jalapeno Seafood Cocktail Sauce is a great alternative for seafood lovers who want a little kick in their cocktail sauce. This sauce includes Jack Daniel’s Black Whiskey, and it gives the sauce a nice smoky flavor. 

There is also a good amount of heat from the jalapenos, which helps balance out the cocktail sauce’s sweetness. This sauce has a good texture and is not too runny. It also has a good shelf life, so you can make a big batch and have it on hand whenever you want it. 

Overall, this is a great alternative to the traditional cocktail sauce, and it is one that seafood lovers will enjoy.

Pros:

  • The smoky flavor from Jack Daniel’s Black Whiskey
  • A good amount of heat from jalapenos
  • Good texture
  • Long shelf life

Cons:

  • It may be too spicy for some people
  • Might not have enough sweetness for some people

Best For Dressing Up Shrimp – Sable & Rosenfeld Tipsy Cocktail Sauce

[amazon box=”B00O86RXCA” ]

If you’re looking for a cocktail sauce with a little bit of a kick, then Sable & Rosenfeld Tipsy Cocktail Sauce is the perfect option. This zesty, fresh tomato sauce is spiked with finely grated horseradish, giving it a nice spicy flavor. 

It’s perfect for dressing up shrimp or other seafood dishes, and it also makes a great dip for chips and vegetables. 

The six-jar pack is great for stocking your pantry. This is a great option if you tend to go through a lot of cocktail sauce. The jars are also resealable, so you can keep them fresh for future use. 

All in all, Sable & Rosenfeld Tipsy Cocktail Sauce is a great option for those who like their sauce with a little bit of a kick.

Pros:

  • Zesty, fresh tomato sauce
  • Spiked with finely grated horseradish
  • Perfect for dressing up shrimp or other seafood dishes
  • Great dip for chips and vegetables
  • The six-jar pack is great for stocking your pantry
  • Reseal jars

Cons: 

  • It may be too spicy

Best For Gluten-Free – Heartbeat Hot Sauce – Milder Ones Collection

[amazon box=”B07XPD9B3D” ]

For those who enjoy a little bit of heat in their food but don’t want to be overwhelmed, the Heartbeat Hot Sauce – Milder Ones Collection is a great option. This set includes three different sauce options, each with its unique flavor profile. 

The Dill Pickle Serrano sauce is sour and garlicky with moderate heat. It’s perfect for summer BBQs and can be used on burgers, corn dogs, Caesar salads, macaroni salad, and even tuna sandwiches. 

The Lion’s Mane Heatonist No. 4 Piri Piri sauce is a contemporary spin on Piri Piri sauces. It features Lion’s Mane mushrooms for a wallop of umami, lemon for acidity, and paprika for mild smoke. This sauce has it all! 

The Jalapeño sauce is a milder option blended with genuine jalapeño and matured serrano peppers to provide the characteristic Heartbeat taste with a wonderfully balanced amount of heat. 

All of the sauces in the Heartbeat Hot Sauce – Milder Ones Collection are handcrafted and fermented in batch production in Canada. They’re also gluten-free, preservative-free, and vegan. 

So, no matter your dietary restrictions, you can enjoy these delicious sauces without worry.

Pros:

  • Three different sauce options
  • Handcrafted and fermented in batch production in Canada
  • Gluten-free, preservative-free, and vegan

Cons:

  • None

Hoffman House Shrimp and Seafood Sauce

[amazon box=”B0083ZZWOS” ]

Looking for a delicious, healthier alternative to the cocktail sauce? Look no further than Hoffman House Shrimp and Seafood Sauce! This zesty sauce is made with real shrimp and crab meat and is perfect for dipping or as a sandwich spread. 

It comes in a handy, resealable jar so you can enjoy it again and again. With no added preservatives or artificial flavors, you can feel good about serving Hoffman House Shrimp and Seafood Sauce to your family and friends.

However, this sauce may not be for you for those who don’t like the “fishy” taste of seafood. But if you’re looking for a healthier alternative to the cocktail sauce, give Hoffman House Shrimp and Seafood Sauce a try!

Pros:

  • A healthier alternative to cocktail sauce
  • Made with real shrimp and crab meat
  • Comes in a handy, resealable jar
  • No added preservatives or artificial flavors

Cons:

  • It may not be for those who don’t like the “fishy” taste of seafood

Heinz Seafood Sauce

[amazon box=”B06XR224NX” ]

When it comes to seafood sauce, Heinz is a classic brand that has been around for years. This particular sauce is perfect for those who want to add a little bit of home-cooking flair to their favorite meals. 

The chili sauce is a great way to improve the flavor of meatloaf, spaghetti sauce, and pork chops. It can also be used as a foundation for chicken or steak fondue. This product is also perfect for making dips and salsa. All you need to do is add some sour cream to it, and you’re good to go. 

The 285ml bottle is great for those who want to have some on hand for multiple meals. It’s also easy to store and doesn’t take up much space. 

Heinz Seafood Sauce is a great alternative to the cocktail sauce because it is packed with flavor and has a variety of uses. It’s a versatile product that any home cook should have in their pantry.

Pros:

  • Great for adding home cooking flair to favorite meals
  • Chili sauce is a great way to improve the flavor of meatloaf, spaghetti sauce, and pork chops
  • Can also be used as a foundation for chicken or steak fondue
  • 285ml bottle is a great size

Cons:

  • None

Old Bay Sauce Cocktail

[amazon box=”B000B6MUHO” ]

For those who enjoy shrimp but not the sometimes bland taste of the cocktail sauce, Old Bay Sauce Cocktail is the perfect alternative. This sauce is much more flavorful, with a hint of spice that makes it stand out. 

The shrimp themselves are also of higher quality, so you can be sure that you’re getting a good product. Its texture is also a bit thicker, so it clings to the shrimp better. 

Its 8-ounce jar is also a good value, as it’s enough to provide dipping sauce for a large group of people. It does not contain any high fructose corn syrup and is also gluten-free.

Cocktail sauce is an essential part of any shrimp dish, and Old Bay Sauce Cocktail is the perfect option for those who want something a little more flavorful. It’s a great value and is sure to please everyone at your next gathering.

Pros:

  • More flavorful than traditional cocktail sauce
  • Hint of spice
  • Higher quality shrimp
  • Thicker texture
  • Good value
  • Gluten-free

Cons:

  • None

Master Chef John Exquisite XO Sauce

[amazon box=”B096YPKJ13″ ]

If you’re a fan of Chinese cuisine, then you’ll love Master Chef John Exquisite XO Sauce. This sauce is made with dried scallops, ham, dried shrimp, Thai red pepper, king oyster mushrooms, and oyster sauce, giving it a unique and flavor-packed taste.

Because it’s handcrafted in small batches in North America, you can be sure that each bottle of XO Sauce is of the highest quality. No preservatives or flavor enhancers are added, so you can enjoy the pure, authentic taste of Hong Kong cuisine.

Whether you’re looking for an appetizer sauce or something to enhance your favorite dish, XO Sauce is a great choice. It’s infused with over 30 years of gourmet expertise, so you can be sure you’re getting a delicious, high-quality sauce.

So if you’re looking for a unique and flavor-packed Chinese sauce, be sure to check out Master Chef John Exquisite XO Sauce. You won’t be disappointed!

Pros:

  • Unique and flavor-packed
  • Handcrafted in small batches in North America
  • No preservatives or flavor enhancers added
  • Great for appetizers or enhancing favorite dishes

Cons:

  • None

Legal Sea Foods House Cocktail Sauce

[amazon box=”B07KJRC63W” ]

Looking for a delicious and easy-to-make cocktail sauce alternative? Look no further than Legal Sea Foods House Cocktail Sauce! Made with a blend of fresh ingredients, including diced tomatoes, horseradish, and spices, this sauce is perfect for dipping or as a condiment on your favorite seafood dishes.

Its texture is slightly chunky, and its flavor is zesty with a kick of heat from the horseradish. The diced tomatoes add a touch of sweetness and acidity to balance out the flavors. 

The best part about Legal Sea Foods House Cocktail Sauce is its versatility. You can use it as a dip for shrimp or other seafood or even as a condiment on burgers or sandwiches. 

It is also great for grilling, so if you are looking for a new way to enjoy your grilled seafood, this sauce is a perfect option.

Pros:

  • Made with fresh ingredients
  • Perfect for dipping or as a condiment
  • Zesty flavor with a kick of heat
  • Versatile and great for grilling

Cons:

  • Some may find the flavor to be too spicy

Dennis’ Horseradish Seafood Lover’s Variety Pack

[amazon box=”B003WM7ILW” ]

If you’re looking for a delicious and healthy alternative to the cocktail sauce, look no further than Dennis’ Horseradish Seafood Lover’s Variety Pack. 

This variety pack includes one original horseradish and two horseradish seafood sauces, perfect for adding a little spice to your seafood meals.

Horseradish is a nutritional powerhouse that packs a punch of flavor. This little root is low in fat and high in fiber, and it is naturally rich in many important minerals, including vitamin C, calcium, potassium, and antioxidants. 

Horseradish is also a plant-strong in sulfur, which can help cleanse nasal passages and improve general health.

In addition to being a great cocktail sauce alternative, Dennis’ Horseradish Seafood Lover’s Variety Pack is also perfect for elevating your meals. This original classic goes well with steak, shucked oysters, and deli sandwiches. 

You can also use it to make burger sauce, spicy mayonnaise, or horseradish mayonnaise. Or, add a teaspoon of horseradish to your next Caesar or Bloody Mary for a distinct spicy punch.

If you’re looking for a unique and healthy gift for the foodie in your life, look no further than Dennis’ Horseradish Seafood Lover’s Variety Pack. This variety pack makes a great Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, or Christmas present.

Pros:

  • A source of many vitamins and minerals
  • A punch of flavor
  • Perfect for those who enjoy spicy food
  • Can be used in a variety of dishes

Cons:

  • It may be too spicy for some people

Lee Kum Kee Seafood XO Sauce

[amazon box=”B002ZB8K18″ ]

Looking for an alternative to the cocktail sauce? Look no further than Lee Kum Kee Seafood XO Sauce. This sauce is made with dried shrimp, soybean oil, and dried scallops. It’s a great way to add some extra flavor to your seafood dishes.

Lee Kum Kee Seafood XO Sauce is full of traditional Asian flavors. This sauce can be used to make a dipping sauce for some seafood dishes such as steamed shrimp, steamed crab, steamed clams, etc. People often use it as a seasoning for dishes such as grilled lobster, fried shrimp, or some Thai seafood dishes.

However, those who are allergic to seafood should be careful with this sauce as it contains ingredients such as shrimp, scallops, etc. People who do not like Asian flavors should not use it because their taste is a bit strong.

It provides low-calorie and high-flavor, two things that are essential in a good cocktail sauce. So if you’re looking for a delicious alternative to the Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce, look no further than Lee Kum Kee Seafood XO Sauce.

Pros:

  • Made with dried shrimp, soybean oil, and dried scallops
  • Adds extra flavor to seafood dishes
  • Low calorie
  • High flavor

Cons:

  • None

Heinz Original Cocktail Sauce

[amazon box=”B0004N0HQK” ]

Heinz Cocktail Sauce is the perfect condiment for those who like a little more zing in their cocktail sauce. This sauce is made with a unique blend of spices and has a slightly tangy flavor that livens up shrimp or any other seafood dish. 

Because it’s from Heinz, you know it’s going to be good. This is a great alternative to the bland ketchup-based sauces out there. And, at only 60 calories per serving, it’s a guilt-free way to enjoy your favorite cocktails. Heinz Cocktail Sauce is also fat-free and gluten-free. 

It comes with a familiar container and is easy to pour spout. Heinz Cocktail Sauce is a great addition to any party or gathering where the seafood is being served. It’s also perfect for those who like to add a little extra flavor to their meals. 

Pros:

  • Tangy and flavorful
  • Great for seafood dishes
  • Only 60 calories per serving
  • Fat-free and gluten-free
  • Comes with a familiar container

Cons:

  • None

Beaver Seafood Tartar Sauce

[amazon box=”B00MUY7B4C” ]

When it comes to finding the perfect cocktail sauce, many people turn to Beaver Seafood Tartar Sauce. This gourmet fish sauce is made with capers and dill, giving it a unique flavor that is perfect for any seafood dish. 

The versatile relish can be used in many recipes as a condiment or ingredient. In addition, the bottle can be squeezed, making it easy to use. 

Oregon has been producing specialty condiments since 1929. The company’s award-winning products are made with quality ingredients and have a reputation for being the best in the business. 

If you are looking for a great alternative to the cocktail sauce, Beaver Seafood Tartar Sauce is a great option.

Pros:

  • Gourmet fish sauce made with capers and dill
  • A unique flavor that is perfect for any seafood dish
  • Can be used as a condiment or ingredient in many recipes
  • The bottle can be squeezed, making it easy to use
  • Award-winning product

Cons:

  • None

Club House Cocktail Sauce

[amazon box=”B075RWFQNS” ]

If you’re a fan of seafood, then you’ll love House Autry Cocktail Sauce! This sauce is perfect for shrimp, clams, oysters, fish, or any other seafood dish. It’s gluten-free and free of artificial flavors, so you can enjoy it without worry. 

The tangy taste and spicy kick will add some serious flavor to your meal. With this sauce, you can finally enjoy seafood the way it was meant to be enjoyed. It goes well with all sorts of seafood, so you can experiment to find your favorite pairing.

House Autry Cocktail Sauce is the perfect way to add some flavor to your seafood. With its tangy taste and spicy kick, you’ll love it on all your favorite seafood dishes. 

Pros:

  • Gluten-free
  • Free of artificial flavors
  • Adds serious flavor to your meal
  • Goes well with all sorts of seafood

Cons:

  • Some may find the taste too tangy
  • It may be too spicy for some

About Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce

trader joe's cocktail sauce

Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce is a delicious, easy-to-use condiment that can be used in a variety of recipes. It is made with all-natural ingredients and contains no high fructose corn syrup. The sauce is perfect for seafood, chicken, and steak dishes.

It tastes great on its own or as a dipping sauce. It can also be used in marinades or as a glaze.

Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce is made with fresh tomatoes, diced onions, garlic, grated horseradish root, cayenne pepper, and vinegar. It is free of preservatives and artificial flavors.

This sauce is a great addition to any kitchen. It is versatile and can be used in many different dishes. It is also healthy and made with all-natural ingredients. Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce is a great choice for anyone looking for a delicious, easy-to-use condiment.

Factors To Consider When Choosing A Cocktail Sauce

When it comes to cocktail sauce, there are a lot of factors to consider. Some sauces are sweeter than others, while others have a spicier kick. And then there’s the matter of thickness – some sauces are thin and runny, while others are nice and thick. How do you decide which sauce is right for you? 

Read on for some tips on what to look for when choosing a cocktail sauce.

The Taste Of The Sauce

trader joe's cocktail sauce

When choosing a cocktail sauce, it is important to consider the taste of the sauce. Some sauces are spicier than others, while others are more acidic. It is important to find a sauce that will compliment the flavor of the seafood being eaten. 

A spicy sauce can overpower delicate seafood, while a mild sauce will not add any flavor. An acidic sauce can also make seafood taste sour. It is important to find a balance when choosing a sauce.

The Ingredients Used In The Sauce

It is also important to consider the ingredients used. Some sauces are made with high-quality ketchup, while others use lower-quality ingredients. Ingredients such as vinegar and spices can vary in flavor and intensity, so it is important to select a sauce that will complement the flavors of your dish.

The Brand Of The Sauce

When choosing a cocktail sauce, the sauce’s brand is essential. Some brands have a longer history than others, and this can be a deciding factor when choosing a sauce to accompany your seafood dish. 

For example, a brand like Heinz has been around for over 100 years and is known for its quality products. Therefore, when choosing a Heinz cocktail sauce, you can be confident that you are getting a high-quality product.

trader joe's cocktail sauce

The Price Of The Sauce

When considering the price of a cocktail sauce, it is important to factor in the cost per ounce. Some cocktail sauces are more expensive than others but may be worth the price if they are of high quality. It is also important to consider the ingredients used in a special sauce. 

For example, if you are looking for a gluten-free or vegan sauce, you may need to pay a bit more for a premium sauce. Ultimately, the price of a cocktail sauce should not be the only factor you consider when making your purchase decision. 

FAQs

What Is In Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce?

Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce is made with tomatoes, prepared horseradish, white vinegar, cayenne pepper, sugar, and salt. All these ingredients give the sauce its unique flavor.

Is Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce Gluten-Free?

Trader Joe’s does not have a gluten-free certification, but the company states that its cocktail sauce is considered gluten-free. That said, people with severe gluten allergies should still take caution and read the ingredients list to make sure the sauce does not contain any gluten-containing ingredients.

Is Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce Vegan?

Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce is vegan, according to the ingredients listed on the company’s website. The sauce is made with chili sauce, tomatoes, distilled white vinegar, sugar, horseradish, salt, onion powder, and garlic powder. It does not contain any animal products.

trader joe's cocktail sauce

Does Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce Have Sugar?

Yes, Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce has sugar. It contains 6 grams of sugar per serving. It also has a bit of a sweet taste. So, if you’re looking for savory sauce, this may not be the best option.

How Do I Use Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce?

Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce can be used as a dipping sauce for seafood or as a condiment for burgers and hot dogs. It is also great in tuna or egg salad sandwiches. You can use it as a seasoning for grilled meats or mix it with mayonnaise to make a spicy aioli. 

The cocktail sauce can also be used in Bloody Marys or as a base for shrimp cocktails. Just add some vodka, tomato juice, and spices to taste. 

Where Can I Buy Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce?

You can buy Trader Joe’s Cocktail sauce at most Trader Joe’s stores. You can also purchase it online if you cannot find it at your local store.

Can I Freeze Trader Joe’s Cocktail Sauce? 

Yes, you can freeze trader joe’s cocktail sauce. It is best to freeze it in an airtight container so that it does not get freezer burn. When you are ready to use it, let it thaw completely before using it.

However, its taste, texture, and color may change after freezing and thawing. So if you are serving it to guests, it is best to use it within a few days of opening it. If you are just using it for yourself, it will still be safe to eat but may not taste as good.

Conclusion

We’ve got you covered if you’re looking for a Trader Joe’s cocktail sauce alternative. In this article, we’ve rounded up 15 of the best substitutes on the market. We’ve got you covered whether you’re looking for something spicy or tangy. So what are you waiting for? Get cooking!

[amazon box=”B001SB54JC” ]

We hope you enjoyed our taste test of Try Me Sauce Tiger. This sauce was a clear favorite among all of the seafood sauces we tasted. It had a perfect blend of spices that gave it a slightly spicy and tangy flavor without overpowering the delicate flavors of the seafood. Try Me Sauce Tiger is highly recommended to enhance your next seafood dish!

Leave a Comment