Best Salt Water Taffy: Perfect Treat For Any Candy Lover

Salt water taffy is a delicious, chewy candy that has been enjoyed by people all over the world for many years. There are many benefits to eating salt water taffy, including improved oral health, weight loss, and energy levels.

Checking out our review to pick the Best Salt Water Taffy

  • Best for stylish design: [amazon link=”B074HDKK8H” title=”Shriver’s Salt Water Taffy” /]
  • Best for non-allergenic shellac: [amazon link=”B0779221BW” title=”Taffy Shop Create Assorted Saltwater Taffy” /]
  • Best for great gift: [amazon link=”B00E5MDH2W” title=”Taffy Shop Caramel Lovers Mix Salt Water Taffy” /]
  • Best for natural ingredients: [amazon link=”B00E5MQ0AS” title=”Taffy Shop Strawberry Cheesecake Salt Water Taffy” /]
  • Best for sugar free: [amazon link=”B08957XBJW” title=”Taffy Shop Creamy Eggnog Salt Water Taffy” /]

[amazon bestseller=”Best Salt Water Taffy” items=”20″ ]

Best Salt Water Taffy Reviews 2022

Shriver’s Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B074HDKK8H” ]

While we love caramels, it is difficult to find a caramel we do not like. However, the company used non-allergenic shellac on the sticky part of the caramels which would be very difficult for us to take.

This sweet treat is a nice change from the classic saltwater taffy found at the boardwalk. These taffies are made with real butter, vanilla, and strawberry flavoring.

Shriver’s is the oldest business on the boardwalk in Ocean City, New Jersey. This is the original store founded in 1912. Shriver’s has a catalog that comes out yearly with its new products and seasonal items.

Shriver’s Salt Water Taffy is a must-have treat on the beach. Known for their famous candy, this sweet and salty treat is a “must”

Taffy is a candy that is typically made with sugar, corn syrup, and water. Taffy makes use of glycerin to help maintain the shape of their product and because of this, taffy is not as popular as it once was.

Shriver’s is the oldest business on the boardwalk in Ocean City, New Jersey. The Ocean City shore is lined with taffy shops that have been there for a lifetime.

Pros

-Non-allergenic shellac

-Famous brand

-Nice design

Cons

-Nothing

Taffy Shop Create Assorted Saltwater Taffy

[amazon box=”B0779221BW” ]

This is a great gift for that person in your life who loves an unusual box full of taffy. Plus, you get to select the amount of taffy (try not to be greedy!).

Although it had a short shelf life and there were some packaging issues, the taffy was well made, chewy, and delicious. This is definitely a must-buy for taffy lovers or those who have never tried taffy.

It’s hard to beat an authentic taffy shop for a product like this. The candy is great for its healthful ingredients and high-quality production. The taffy can be broken up into pieces or eaten straight from the tub. Both ways are great.

Every person deserves to have the best caramel taffy, and this Taffy Shop Create Assorted Saltwater Taffy is exactly what it says it is. You are given a variety of classic, exotic, and gourmet flavors that all have a rich, salty, sweet taste.

They have around 150 different taffy flavors to choose from! Some of the flavors include Crazy Party Mix, Refreshing Lemonade, and Strawberry All My Luvs.

This month’s selection of taffy flavors is amazing! This package contains seven different taffy flavors, each of which is a perfect accompaniment to their favorite candy bars, fudge, cheesecake, ice cream, ice cream cake, sundae, or truffles.

Pros

-Nice package

-Great gift

-Caramel smell

Cons

-None

Taffy Shop Caramel Lovers Mix Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B00E5MDH2W” ]

Everyone knows the old joke about the woman who goes to the drug store for a headache tablet and comes home with two prescription bottles, one for a headache and one for heartburn.

The Taffy Shop Caramel Lovers Mix Salt Water Taffy is a wonderful treat for anyone who enjoys the sweet sensation of caramel. The taste of the caramel is light, with a hint of salt to give the sweet treat some balance.

The Taffy Shop is one of the industry’s leaders, and these Caramel Lovers Mix salt water taffies are our favorite taffy in the entire shop. It’s not too sweet, not too salty, and the caramel topping is smooth and creamy.

This caramel lovers mix saltwater taffy is perfect for anyone looking for a sweet fix without the added sugar.

This is an excellent candy to purchase if you are into healthy food and also into tasty treats. What is great about it is that it is a mix of salty with sweet and a little bit of artificial and natural flavors.

These candy bars are a delicious, sugar-free, peanut-free alternative to the more traditional candy bars. They are made from pure and natural ingredients, with only 14 calories per serving.

Pros

-Sweet fix without the added sugar

-Peanut-free alternative

-Natural ingredients

Cons

-Nothing

Taffy Shop Strawberry Cheesecake Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B00E5MQ0AS” ]

This taffy is very enjoyable in taste and texture. You can always tell if a taffy is produced in America because it has a consistent flavor and texture no matter which flavor you get.

You don’t need me to tell you about the Taffy Shop. Everyone in Ohio knows about the taffy shops. They’re usually in the same shopping center as the department stores, clothing stores, and ice cream shops.

While this taffy would be more enjoyable if it wasn’t so hard, the flavor is delicious. The taffy is chewy but it tastes as if you’ve bitten into a piece of melted strawberry cheesecake. The packaging is pretty fun, too.

The Taffy Shop Strawberry Cheesecake Gourmet Salt Water Taffy is great! It has a nice, subtle flavor that isn’t too overpowering. The box has over 200 pieces of taffy in it, which will last a while if you ration yourself.

The Taffy Shop Caramel Lovers Mix Salt Water Taffy is a wonderful treat for anyone who enjoys the sweet sensation of caramel. The taste of the caramel is light, with a hint of salt to give the sweet treat some balance.

Pros

-Non-allergenic shellac

-Famous brand

-Nice design

Cons

-Nothing

Taffy Shop Creamy Eggnog Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B08957XBJW” ]

Taffy is an American-based company that provides a variety of food-related products, including caramels, popcorn, and chocolate products.

This Taffy Shop eggnog salt water taffy is the best taffy in the industry. The saltwater taffy is soft and chewy, with the sweetness of an eggnog flavor.

This is the best candy I have ever tasted! The caramel has such a rich, smooth flavor. The best part is that it does not have milk or dairy in it.

The Taffy Shop Creamy Eggnog Salt Water Taffy is a perfect addition to your candy bag. Taffy Shop offers a variety of other flavored taffy that you can buy individually, or buy the whole bag in a variety of taffy flavors. The Taffy Shop brand Taffy is a highly-rated holiday favorite. This particular Taffy comes in many different flavors and is available in a package of six to nine pieces.

This taffy is the perfect blend of sweet and salty. It’s a great piece of candy to keep around the house as a sweet treat or as a stocking stuffer. The creamy texture and crisp flavor make it a big hit with everyone. Pure delicious. Not grainy at all. You would never know it was a no-sugar-added taffy if you didn’t know. So even if you don’t like sweet taffy and only want salt, it tastes like the real deal.

Pros

-Perfect blend of sweet and salty

-Pure delicious

-Not grainy at all

Cons

-Nothing

Taffy Shop Cookie Dough Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B00DWI8QTE” ]

Shriver’s is a family-owned and operated business that has been creating and selling taffy since 1909. Shriver’s is committed to providing the highest quality taffy on the market with a family atmosphere.

This is a great treat for all of your friends and family. If you are going to be throwing a party or family get-together, this is the perfect item to bring. Either give out the amazing snacks at the party or get the bag and make your own so you have them on hand.

The Taffy Shop Cookie Dough saltwater taffy is as good as it sounds. It is a wonderful taffy and perfect for a fun flavor with a nice texture. It has a delicious coconut chocolate flavor and does not taste fake.

The overall flavors of the Taffy Shop’s cookie dough saltwater taffy taste just like their original taffy. There are multiple flavors in each bag, but the pack comes with four flavors which include an original recipe and two additional “mix-ins”

One of our favorite parts of fall is the taffy shops. While most stores only sell taffy during the months of October and November, some stores will keep their shelves stocked in anticipation of the holiday season.

Pros

-Nice texture

-Fun flavor

-Not taste fake

Cons

-None

Taffy Shop Sweet Peppermint Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B00E5MPOUA” ]

This taffy is a great combination of sweet and salty. The creamy sweet peppermint flavor is a nice twist from the standard saltwater taffy. The saltwater taffy flavor is not overpowering. Taffy Shop’s Sweet Peppermint salt water taffy is made with only all-natural ingredients, making it a healthy treat for all ages to enjoy. A fantastic range of pre-made smoothies! My kids love picking these out of the fridge and having a cool, sweet treat. They’re easy to make and take only seconds to mix.

This taffy is made from real sweet peppermint taffy. It has a great mild taffy flavor with a peppermint kick to it. This taffy is excellent, it has a sweet peppermint flavor that both adults and children enjoy. The taffy shop’s candy taffy is a guarantee that the purchase of this product will be worth the money.

This Taffy Shop taffy is the perfect stocking stuffer or Secret Santa gift. It’s soft and chewy but doesn’t leave your teeth feeling sticky or gross. The peppermint flavor is subtle and not overpowering but still has a bit of an aftertaste. Looking for a candy that can be enjoyed any time of the year? Taffy Shop made their saltwater taffy to be enjoyed year-round. It comes in over 100 flavors, including strawberry, red velvet, salted caramel, and more.

Though this taffy comes in a light green color, it has a strong peppermint scent that you can smell a little of it when taking a bite. The candy is chewy and is not too hard or too soft. This taffy is perfect for anyone who loves to enjoy the sweet and rich flavors of peppermint and saltwater taffy. The perfect combination of the two results in a perfect balance of sweet and salty flavors.

Pros

-Strong peppermint scent 

-Chewy 

-Rich flavors of peppermint 

Cons

-Not found yet

Taffy Shop Cherry Cherry Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B00DWI8IFG” ]

Taffy Shop Cherry Cherry saltwater taffy is scrumptious and tasty. The light salt flavor and color of the taffy are hard to resist. The texture is slightly chewy with a soft bite.

Taffy Shop’s Cherry Cherry taffy is a great choice for people who love salty and sweet treats. This taffy has a great combination of salt and sweet flavors, making it perfect for your sweet tooth.

Taffy Shop’s Cherry Cherry saltwater taffy is an excellent way to get salty, sweet, and chewy all at the same time. This taffy is easy to eat and doesn’t get hard like regular taffy.

The Taffy Shop Cherry Cherry Salt Water Taffy is an amazing and tasty treat made in the USA. The taffy has a different spin from a typical taffy.

This item is perfect for making gift baskets, stocking stuffers, and gift exchanges. This sweet and tart Taffy Shop Cherry Cherry Salt Water Taffy has just the right amount of chewy and soft without a hard chew. It isn’t too sticky and doesn’t break apart easily.

Taffy is probably America’s most famous candy. It was the first saltwater taffy invented in New York City in 1876. The Taffy Shop Company of New York City is the oldest taffy store in America, and one of the oldest candy stores in the world

Pros

-Perfect for your sweet tooth.

-Perfect for making gift baskets

-Has a different spin from a typical taffy

Cons

-Nothing

Taffy Shop Peaches & Cream Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B00DWI7A1E” ]

This taffy is the perfect treat for any candy lover. Its creamy and chewy consistency is so satisfying. The bags have a strong taffy scent, but it is not overpowering.

If you’re looking for a new variety of taffy that is both gluten-free and peanut-free, this is a perfect choice. The taffy has a very smooth texture that is chewy without being too tough.

This taffy is absolutely delicious! The peach flavor is just right with a subtle buttery flavor. The taffy itself is soft and chewy and hard to stop eating once you start. It is not so soft that it gets hard or chewy.

This taffy is one of my favorites! It is a little thick so it is easy to carry around and also perfect for making a couple of yourself for a sweet treat. It is delicious and I always look forward to trying the new flavors that are offered.

This is the best taffy ever! It is softer than regular taffy and tastes wonderful! If you are expecting a taffy with a strong flavor, you may be disappointed. However, this taffy is awesome!

There are few things as refreshing as the sweet taste of peaches mixed with delicious cream, which is why we mixed them together to make this gourmet taffy.

Pros

-Perfect treat for any candy lover

-Smooth texture

-Not grainy at all

Cons

-Nothing

Taffy Shop Peanut Butter Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B08958YRN2″ ]

This Taffy Shop Peanut Butter Salt Water Taffy is an excellent choice for anyone looking for a unique and delicious treat.

This taffy is perfect for game day parties or football season. The Peanut Butter Taffy is great on its own or as a complement to any other candy available.

The Peanut Butter Taffy is always in stock at the candy factory and is a great treat for all types of celebrations, whether the occasion is a baby shower, mother’s day, father’s day, Halloween, or Christmas.

Taffy is the most iconic candy of all time, and for a good reason. If there were a national taffy day, no one would be able to make it through the first few days of school without being caught raiding from the box.

This taffy is one of a kind and totally worth every piece! We’ve all heard the phrase “You can’t eat just one”, and for good reason, once you’ve tasted this peanut butter and chocolate taffy you’ll realize how true that statement is.

Taffy Shop is a company that specializes in no-bake-filled candy treats. Each box of this product is stuffed with the amount of candy you would expect for the price.

The Taffy Shop peanut butter salt water taffy is amazing. It is so smooth and delicious that it’s hard to stop eating. If you have never had this taffy you will never look back. The combination of peanut butter and saltwater is addicting.

People who purchase this product are usually fans of saltwater taffy, which is known to contain occasional traces of peanut butter. Most, however, claim that they would not notice any traces of peanut butter if at all.

Pros

-Non-allergenic shellac

-Famous brand

-Nice design

Cons

-Nothing

Taffy Shop Creamsicle Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B00E5MOZY6″ ]

The best part about this Taffy Shop creamsicle saltwater taffy is that you do not have to be an expert to pull it off. This taffy is a little easier to work with and does not crumble, which can give it a messy appearance.

This taffy is perfect for those who have a sweet tooth and love the nostalgic flavors of childhood.

Taffy is like crack to most people, and the majority of people will eat just about anything in the flavor they desire.

This taffy is made with the best ingredients, it is made in the USA and doesn’t need refrigeration once opened.

The Creamsicle Salt Water Taffy by Taffy Shop really does taste just like its namesake. One bite and you will be hooked on the sweet flavor and addictively chewy texture that only saltwater taffy can give.

This taffy was nothing special. The flavor was mild and not very sweet. The texture was chewy, not hard, and crunchy. If you love fruit flavors and low-sweetness taffy, then you will probably like this product.

This taffy is the perfect choice for anyone who loves the flavor of cream-filled ice cream or a sweet, mint chocolate chip.

Pros

-Nice package

-Great gift

-Caramel smell

Cons

-None

Taffy Shop Lemon Meringue Pie Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B00DWI6COU” ]

This taffy is made in Milford, NH, and is a small town favorite. Only at the Taffy Shop is the taffy made by hand and popped with the traditional pop machine. The result is a taffy with the right texture and flavor.

Taffy Shop Lemon Meringue Pie is the perfect sweet tooth fix that can be enjoyed by the whole family. It’s sure to satisfy even the most finicky of eaters. This taffy has a truly unique and delicious taste that has been enjoyed by many.

This taffy is a must-have for all candy lovers. The buttery and sweet lemon meringue taste is addictive. This taffy is thick and chewy which makes it perfect for dipping in ice cream, or chocolate.

This is one of my favorite treats at the Taffy Shop. I have tried several flavors and the lemon meringue pie taffy was the best. The taffy is light and airy, with a bit of sweetness.

Lemon taffy is one of the most popular flavors that candy stores carry. Known as being sour and sweet at the same time, it is a sweet and sour delight.

This taffy is incredibly addictive. The base has a great mouth-feel, but the flavor is what really puts this in the “top 3” category.

Pros

-Non-allergenic shellac

-Famous brand

-Nice design

Cons

-Nothing

Taffy Shop Rad Raspberry Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B00DWI7X0M” ]

This taffy has a delicate yet sweet raspberry flavor that makes it a great treat for an autumn or winter day. It’s made with real food ingredients and uses only the best organic cane sugar.

This taffy is made with certified, gluten-free ingredients. The saltwater taffy has a smooth, chewable texture. The taffy shop even serves a side of sparkling lemon soda with the taffy.

Taffy Shop Rad Raspberry saltwater taffy is delicious and comes in many different flavors. It is available in a variety of different colors and is a perfect addition to any candy collection.

This taffy is the perfect sweet treat for a family gathering or Sunday night roasts. Nothing tastes better than warm raspberry candy for a grown-up candy. It is sweet, salty, and light enough to be eaten without feeling heavy.

Taffy Shop makes some of the best taffy in the world. Red Raspberry is a great choice for all of the candy lovers in your life. It makes the perfect soft candy that can be shared with friends.

This taffy is perfect for any candy lover. The tart, sour, and sweet raspberry flavors are sure to please any taffy lover. The taffy is soft, chewy, and sweet. The saltwater taffy provides a unique and different candy treat.

Pros

-Perfect blend of sweet and salty

-Pure delicious

-Not grainy at all

Cons

-Nothing

Taffy Shop Maple Bacon Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B089583YTL” ]

These taffies are not only delicious, but they are gluten-free and dairy-free, so they are great for anyone with a food allergy. The maple taffy is amazing, with a delicious maple taste.

Is your love for bacon as great as ours? If you’re a true lover of all things bacon, then you’ll love this taffy. It’s got a thin layer of bacon-flavored salt on top, with a thick layer of luscious maple syrup on the bottom.

If your taste buds have been longing for the perfect blend of sweet and salty, we think you will love this Maple Bacon taffy.

Taffy Shop makes the best bacon taffy! Once you have tried the sweet, salty, and delicious taste of Maple Bacon taffy, you will never be able to go back to plain old taffy again.

This taffy tastes just like actual maple bacon, but without the carbs and calories. Maple syrup is a traditional candy topping, and in this case, it is sweetened with sea salt and coconut oil.

This taffy is completely and completely delicious, thanks to the deep chocolate, caramel, and salty flavors of the Maple Bacon, no matter how many times you’ve had it or how many times you’ve told yourself it’s not your thing.

Pros

-Strong peppermint scent 

-Chewy 

-Rich flavors of peppermint 

Cons

-Not found yet

Taffy Shop Sassy Sours Mix Salt Water Taffy

[amazon box=”B089KQP1WZ” ]

Sassy Sours is well-known as the only choice for anyone looking for amazing bacon flavor. These hand-crafted taffies taste just like the amazing flavors found in the restaurants famous for their incredible tots and nuggets.

Taffy Shop sweet and salty taffy is great for all ages, so it’s a great gift for your siblings or friends who love sweet and salty. Only 6 taffy pieces are needed to make one pound (454g) of taffy.

After trying the Taffy Shop’s previously sampled Maple Bacon, we were eager to try their other flavors. This Salt Water Mix Taffy was a great choice. The deep red color, delicious sugar and coconut flavor, and chewy texture made this taffy a hit.

Most of the taffy flavors are based on candy flavors that you would expect. The Bacon flavor is different, not just because it has bacon in it, but because it combines the taste of bacon and maple syrup and to some people, that’s probably an excellent combination.

Pros

-Perfect blend of sweet and salty

-Pure delicious

-Not grainy at all

Cons

-Nothing

Best Salt Water Taffy Benefits

Best Salt Water Taffy

Saltwater taffy is a delicious, chewy candy that has been enjoyed by people all over the world for many years. There are many benefits to eating saltwater taffy, including improved oral health, weight loss, and energy levels.

Saltwater taffy is a type of candy that is made from sugar, corn syrup, salt, water, and flavoring. It is often chewy and has a texture that is similar to taffy. Saltwater taffy is a popular treat, and there are many different flavors available.

You can make your own saltwater taffy at home with some simple ingredients and a little bit of time. You can get creative by mixing the flavors together or adding in some other ingredients for an even sweeter treat.

One of the great benefits of saltwater taffy is that it has a low glycemic index, which means that it won’t spike your blood sugar levels. The high protein content also makes it a perfect snack before or after a workout.

The truth is that this candy is delicious and healthy. It’s hard to believe that something that tastes so good can also be good for you!

Factors To Consider When Choosing Best Salt Water Taffy

Best Salt Water Taffy

Saltwater taffy is a delicious and traditional treatment that can be enjoyed by people of all ages. There are many different flavors and brands of saltwater taffy available, so it can be tough to decide which one is the best. Here are some factors to consider when choosing the best saltwater taffy.

Flavor

Most taffy brands come in at least one flavor, but the best-salted water taffy brands have a huge variety of flavors to choose from. If you aren’t big on sweets, check out their flavored selections and you may be surprised. Some even carry savory options that are just as mouth-watering as their sweet ones.

Color

The color of the taffy is a good indicator of the quality of the candy. Saltwater taffy comes in various colors. Pink, white, red, green, and blue is just some of the colors available on store shelves. The more natural the color, the better the quality of the saltwater taffy.

Price

The cost of saltwater taffy does not vary greatly from one brand to another. That said, there is a difference in quality when it comes to cheap and expensive taffy. A good rule of thumb is to avoid very cheap products that are usually made with low-quality ingredients and a sloppy manufacturing process.

Best Salt Water Taffy

Taste

The best saltwater taffy is tasty. Some of the taffies that are not so good taste like wax, or even plastic. You will know this by trying the taffy yourself. In some places, you can buy samples to try before buying a whole bag. If you do not like the taffy, it does not matter how salty it is because no one will want to eat it.

Quality

 Check the right quality of saltwater taffy. There are some brands that offer cheap saltwater taffy but they don’t meet the quality standards. If you buy such a product, it may not have an appealing taste or consistency. Look for a brand that is from a reputable company that makes high-quality products. A good example is Pink Dolphin Salt Water Taffy Company which makes the best quality saltwater taffy.

FAQs about Best Salt Water Taffy

What are the ingredients in salt water taffy? 

Saltwater taffy is a traditional candy made by combining sugar, water, and either salt or butter flavoring. It takes approximately 15 minutes to boil the sugar into a syrup that will be poured onto the candy sticks. This is a thin layer of candy that will harden as it cools.

How long does saltwater taffy last? 

Best Salt Water Taffy

Saltwater taffy will generally last for a year, or longer if stored properly. There are a few methods to help extend the shelf life of saltwater taffy on its own. The first is to store the taffy in an airtight container in a cool place. The second is to wrap it in plastic wrap and then tin foil. Lastly, you can place it in a freezer bag and put it in the freezer.

What are some variations of salt water taffy? 

If you prefer not to have saltwater taffy, there are a few other options. The first is sugar-free taffy. The second is chocolate taffy. A third option is a fruit-flavored taffy. Fruit taffy comes in strawberry, blueberry, cherry, and many more flavors. You can also find wine-flavored taffy, beer-flavored taffy, and hard cider-flavored taffy.

Conclusion

Shriver’s Salt Water Taffy is our top pick. This sweet treat is a nice change from the classic saltwater taffy found at the boardwalk. These taffies are made with real butter, vanilla, and strawberry flavoring.

[amazon box=”B074HDKK8H” ]

Hope our review can help you pick the Best Salt Water Taffy for your needs!

Leave a Comment