Dark rums are often used in baking because they have a rich molasses flavor. They’re also perfect for making cocktails and mixed drinks. Therefore, the best dark rum for baking is not always the one you want to drink.
Many different rums have unique flavor profiles that better suit various recipes. For instance, if you’re making a cake or sugary frosting, you’ll want a more robust and flavorful rum than what would be good in something like an alcoholic coffee beverage.
The type of rum will also depend on what kind of dessert you’re preparing- again, for example, spiced desserts often use dark or blackstrap rums because they have bolder flavors that complement spices nicely.
Because of these complications, you feel overwhelmed and confused whenever you choose the products. You don’t know where to start, leading to the inability to make correct decisions.
Our article has made it easy to find the best dark rum for baking by providing reviews of some excellent options so that when it comes time for your following recipe, you’ll know just what to reach for.
Best Dark Rum For Baking Comparison 2023
| No | Name | Image | Best For | Rating | Details |
| 1 | LorAnn Rum Bakery Emulsion, 4 ounce bottle |  | Best for deep rum taste | VIEW PRODUCT | |
| 2 | McCormick Rum Extract With Other Natural Flavors, 1 fl oz (Pack of 6) |  | Best for using for children | VIEW PRODUCT | |
| 3 | Ossoro Baker's Rum Pastry Flavour with 100% Vegetarian (1 Oz) | Food Flavoring | No Sugar Added, Non-GMO, Gluten-Free Flavors | Used to Make Cakes, Snacks, Ice creams, Candies, Baking & More |  | Best for adaptable flavor | VIEW PRODUCT | |
| 4 | McCormick Culinary Imitation Rum Extract, 16 fl oz - One 16 Fluid Ounce Bottle of Rum Extract for Baking, Best for Desserts, Fruit, Sauces and More |  | Best for professional chefs | VIEW PRODUCT | |
| 5 | LorAnn Butter Rum SS Flavor, 1 ounce bottle |  | Best for offering high-quality flavors | VIEW PRODUCT |
Before getting into the article, let’s see our top 5 recommendations:
Best for deep rum taste: LorAnn Rum Bakery Emulsion
Best for using for children: McCormick Rum Extract
Best for adaptable flavor: Ossoro Baker's Rum Pastry Flavour
Best for professional chefs: McCormick Culinary Imitation Rum Extract
Best for offering high-quality flavors: LorAnn Butter Rum SS Flavor
Now, let’s head into the article and see what we’ve got for you!
- Quality Essences from Still Spirits
- This 50ml Bottle Flavours 2.25L of Vodka or spirit
- Add to Vodka to make the drink of your choice
- This is a flavouring (does not include alcohol)
- We have 100s of flavours available from our Shop
- this scent captures the essence of long days spent in the tropical sun and late nights with friends.
- Launched by the design house of malin + goetz
- This feminine fragrance has a blend of bergamot, plum, anise, leather, rum, vanilla, amber, patchouli, and milk.
- Alcohol-free.
- Synthesizes sweet and spicy notes fo
- Quality Essences from Still Spirits
- This 50ml Bottle Flavours 2.25L of Vodka or spirit
- Add to Vodka to make the drink of your choice
- This is a flavouring (does not include alcohol)
- We have 100s of flavours available from our Shop
- Gold medal recipient of The 2020 San Francisco World Spirits Competition. Impossibly Crafted Non-Alcoholic Spirit - Dark Cane Spirit.
- Tasting Notes: Full flavored with notes of caramel, fudge, fig, toasted nuts are enhanced by a long finish featuring maple and vanilla
- How To Enjoy: As a classic mixer. Keep it cold to make your favorite classic including the Sidecar, mixing with Lyre’s Triple Sec & lime juice or shake a Mai Tai using the Lyre’s Cane Spirit range
- To immerse in a full libation experience, go to “Product guides and documents” and click on the USER GUIDE to sign up for a complimentary virtual one-to-one mixology session with our seasoned brand ambassadors. Also, click on the USER MANUAL for our delicious non-alcoholic cocktail recipes designed by our professional mixologists to showcase Lyre’s products in the best proportions aimed at delivering the closest possible match to a mixed original.
- Before your drink arrives, we know you are positively thrilled to begin tasting. Hold fire and resist temptation before you take your first sip neat. Lyre’s best comes to life when made in a delightful cocktail and we have a mixology lesson crafted for you.
- NON-ALCOHOLIC DISTILLED SPIRIT – FLUÈRE is made using state of the art hydrosteam distillation to create a distilled spirit with no alcohol.
- FLUÈRE Spiced Cane Dark Roast has delicious notes of chocolate and coffee in the nose and a sweet, complex flavor. The richness of the Dominican sugar cane blends with hints of tonka bean and spices.
- EASY TO MIX. FLUÈRE Spiced Cane Dark Roast is perfect with Cola and ice (Non-alcoholic cube libre , we call it THE CUBAN) You can also make a delicious non-alcoholic ‘old fashioned’ with it.
- Fluère Spiced Cane intended as an alternative for Rum drinkers.
- ALCOHOL FREE SPIRITS CREATED FOR COCKTAILS ( to make 12 cocktails/mix drinks)
- Package Includes: 1 x RONSIN Non-Alcoholic (0.0%) Rum Alternative 1000ml.
- Produced in Spain by Espadafor.
- A great alcohol-free alternative to rum to be used as a base for amazing mocktails or drank standalone.
- Great for Designated Drivers: Don't forget your alcohol-free guests when selecting drink options!
- Rum alternative perfect for non-alcoholic cocktails.
- Adds rich rum flavor to baked goods and frostings
- Used in restaurants and home gourmet cooking.
- Best Value
- OU Kosher Certified
- Make Your Own Dark Jamaican Rum flavored spirits at home using Swish Barrel Premium Essence. Swish Barrel essences are specially formulated to mimic the taste of premium spirit mash bills. When combined with a neutral spirit such as vodka, moonshine, or grain alcohol the taste can be indistinguishable from many known brands.
- Dark Jamaican Rum Essence is a traditional blend of West Indies dark Navy rums, favored by sailors, buccaneers, wenches and landlubbers alike. Dark rum is a winner at the beach or at parties. The flavor expands and charred oak notes are imparted when aged in a small or mini oak barrel.
- For connoisseur tastes, age your spirits in an authentic Thousand Oaks Barrel! Mini aging barrels will accelerate the aging process due to the higher surface to alcohol ratio of the barrel and provide additional flavor notes inherent only in Top Shelf 10 to 20 year aged products.
- NEW… ECO Friendly Packaging. Swish Barrel Essence now come in soft pack leak proof packaging. Same flavor better package. Soft pack packaging extends the shelf life of the essence and eliminates leaking. Maximize storage of your extra essence.
- Check out our other essence flavors from our spirit making Bootleg Kits; Kentucky Bourbon, Small Batch Bourbon, American Rye Whiskey, Blended Whisky, Canadian Rye Whiskey, Pot Sill Whisky, Absinthe, Port, Wine, Orange Brandy, Texas Corn Whiskey, Barley Whisky, Mexican Corn Whiskey, Japanese Blended Peat Whisky and many more…
- A GREAT OPTION - We don't always want to have another but that doesn't mean we want to go home. Every ArKay beverage is Halal and for those on medication or have compromised immune systems.
- NOT EVERYONE DRINKS - It is increasingly common that your guests are going to want an alternative, and not everyone wants to drink sodas and juices.
- MAKE GREAT ZERO-PROOF COCKTAILS - ArKay gives you the best option in a one to one alcohol alternative. We have the flavor, mouthfeel, heat and nose of each of our alcoholic counterparts and will swap 1 to 1 for any of your favorite cocktails.
- NOT FOR CHILDREN - ArKay has led the pack in changing the landscape of adult beverages since 2011 and although ArKay is alcohol free the flavor and feel is for the sophisticated palates of an adult who want complexity without the alcohol.
- MORE THAN A RITUAL - Arkay Alcohol-Free RUM Award winner by Scottish Spirits Association. Arkay is crafted, not distilled, meaning truly 100% Alcohol Free. Flavors and ingredients are all-natural with no allergens, no sugar, not fat, no carbs, no sweeteners, no alcohol. The result is a spirit alternative that delivers the flavor and experience of the original, without the alcohol.
- Quality Essences from Still Spirits
- This 50ml Bottle Flavours 2.25L of Vodka or spirit
- Add to Vodka to make the drink of your choice
- This is a flavouring (does not include alcohol)
- We have 100s of flavours available from our Shop
- Made with real bay rum oils
- Cools & refreshes
- Includes one gallon and one 16oz bottle
- BUILT FOR COCKTAILS – Our non-alcoholic rum alternative is specially crafted to replace traditional rum 1:1 in the drinks you already know and love. Ritual spirits are made for cocktails and not meant to be consumed straight or neat.
- A HEALTHIER CHOICE – All the warm vanilla, toasted spice, and velvety decadence of dark rum, without the alcohol or calories, for conscious consumption that leaves you at your best.
- AWARD WINNING FLAVOR - The highest rated alcohol free rum alternative ever, certified 93/100 Gold by the Bartender Spirits Awards.
- DESIGNED FOR YOUR LIFESTYLE – Perfect for when you're driving, training, dieting, parenting, staying out late, getting up early, seeking the perfect third drink or abstaining altogether.
- YOUR FAVORITE COCKTAILS, NON-ALCOHOLIC - For non-alcoholic classic like mojitos, pina coladas, daiquiris and mai tais, inspired mixology, simple serves with soda or juice, and everything in between.
- OliveNation Rum Flavor, Extracted from Myer's White and Other Fine Rums, Clear Flavoring Extract for Baking
- Rum extract is used in baking and cooking recipes to give them true rum flavor and add deep, rich flavor note
- PERFECT FOR flavoring cakes, cookies, fillings, frostings, sauces, puddings, and more
- RUM FLAVORING FOR BEVERAGES: Add rum extract to hot or cold beverages; Perfect in eggnog, coffee, cocoa, smoothies
- Non-GMO, Certified Kosher, Vegan, and Gluten Free in a water soluble, clear formulation
- IDEAL RUM ALTERNATIVE: Enjoy a fearlessly flavorful take on a Caribbean-style rum, minus the alcohol
- THE BETTER CHOICE: With only 10 calories, less than 0.5% alcohol by volume, no sweeteners and no sugars, this is your go-to for great rum without the regret
- SPICY SPIRIT: Bring on the heat with hints of contrasting flavors, from cayenne to caramel, nutty to woody
- THE GOOD STUFF: Carefully sourced and tastefully distilled for an authentic rum experience, with fab natural flavors
- A MUST FOR MIXING IT UP: Perfect for rum punches, daiquiris, mojitos, and any other variety of rum cocktail, from the classic to the creative
- Perfect for baking, flavoring drinks and more
- Ingredients all naturally derived
- No Artificial Colors or Flavors
- Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Corn Syrup Free, Kosher
- Crafted in the USA
- SUBTLE SUGARY NOTES AND AROMA: Imitation rum extract recreates the subtle sugary notes and aroma that you associate with rum; features a pleasant, orangey color that enhances all kinds of dishes with a lovely sweetness
- PREMIUM RUM SUBSTITUTE: Made using premium ingredients, this rum flavoring extract makes it easy to substitute 2 teaspoons of extract for 1 tablespoon of dark rum or 1 tablespoon of extract for 5 tablespoons of light rum
- MADE FOR CHEFS: Crafted with chefs in mind, each bottle comes ready to use and contains 16 fluid ounces, making it easy to flavor desserts, sauces and baked goods; dispense individual drops or larger amounts by unscrewing the top
- CONCENTRATED AND VERSATILE: Rum flavoring is perfect for all kinds of menu items that call for rum if the team in your commercial kitchen wants to use a concentrated ingredient that won't affect your dish's texture
- FEEL GOOD RUM FLAVORING: Kosher and gluten-free for a light rum flavor you can feel good about enjoying yourself or serving to your guests; delicious imitation flavors retained even after cooking at high temperatures
- A GREAT CHOICE: We don't always want another, but that doesn't mean we want to go home. ArKay drinks are healthy all natural alcohol alternatives, that are 100% alcohol-free, allergen-free, GMO-free, zero calorie, gluten-free, and vegan- all for those who take medications or have a compromised immune system
- NOT EVERYONE DRINKS - It is increasingly common that your guests are going to want an alternative, and not everyone wants to drink sodas and juices.
- MAKE GREAT ZERO-PROOF COCKTAILS - ArKay gives you the best option in a one to one alcohol alternative. We have the flavor, mouthfeel, heat and nose of each of our alcoholic counterparts and will swap 1 to 1 for any of your favorite cocktails.
- NOT FOR CHILDREN - ArKay has led the pack in changing the landscape of adult beverages since 2011 and although ArKay is alcohol free, the flavor and feel is for the sophisticated palates of adults who want complexity without the alcohol
- MORE THAN A RITUAL - Arkay Alcohol-Free White rum Award winner by Scottish Spirits Association. Arkay is crafted, not distilled, meaning truly 100% Alcohol Free. Flavors and ingredients are all-natural with no allergens, no sugar, not fat, no carbs, no sweeteners, no alcohol. The result is a spirit alternative that delivers the flavor and experience of the original, without the alcohol.
- CLASSIC ALL PURPOSE FRAGRANCE FOR MEN: Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum Cologne is a formula of classic spices with the essence of the bay tree to offer a distinctive scent which is suitable for all occasions. This after shaving cologne soothe skin and treat post-shaving irritations while leaving behind a refreshing tingle! Splash this aftershave freely all over the body to start your day, after your gym workout, after your run and feel refreshed instantly! Keep your suave scent up all day!
- INSTANTLY COOLS, TONES AND REFRESHES SKIN: Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum Cologne has a unique blend of ingredients that helps tone the skin, soothe it, and prevent irritation from erupting due to shaving. Suitable for the most sensitive of skin right after a shave, this antiseptic agent works marvelously at offering a pleasant cooling effect while conditioning pores and treating post-shaving blues like razor nicks, cuts, burns and itch. A definite must-have for every shaving routine!
- INFUSED WITH ESSENCE OF BAY TREE AND EXOTIC SPICES: Bay Rum is one of the timeless ingredients in aromas for men, and Pinaud Clubman Virgin Island Bay Rum does the job at providing it! Infused with the essence of bay tree, it offers a wonderfully rich, deep scent of dark rum with strong overtones of cloves, cinnamon and spices, giving you that intoxicating mix of aromatic delights. Unleash the timeless gentleman in you with this ultra-masculine splash, it’s a guaranteed classic winner!
- CONVENIENT, HANDY, POST SHAVING COLOGNE: Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum Cologne is all you need to stay smelling fresh and clean, leaving you always ready to take on the day. Great to use after shaving to calm skin, right after showering to stay cool, or right before heading out for the night. It comes in a 12-oz bottle, and handy, so you can take it with you anywhere! A little splash of it goes a long way to keep you smelling fresh all day, so you'll find it to last a long time.
- CRUELTY-FREE, MADE IN THE US, TRUSTED FOR GENERATIONS: A true neighborhood barbershop staple, the Pinaud brand and its Clubman line of fine men’s toiletries have been the go-to brand for men’s grooming products. Offering a wide range of popular men’s grooming products, Clubman remains true to the brand’s heritage while bringing to market must-haves driven by market trends. All products are 100 % cruelty-free - never tested on animals and proudly made in the US!
Best Dark Rum For Baking Reviews 2023
LorAnn Rum Bakery Emulsion
- Use LorAnn's Rum flavor Emulsion in any of your frostings and baked goods to impart the deliciously rich flavor of rum without all the alcohol. Use it anywhere you would a rum baking extract - and get more flavorful results!
- 1 teaspoon baking extract = 1 teaspoon emulsion
- Packaged in BPA free, recyclable PET plastic bottles.
- Water Based ( Soluble in Water)
- Gluten Free - Made in USA
We enjoy baking with rum, but we frequently forget to purchase it. LorAnn’s Rum Bakery Emulsion comes in handy if you’re out of rum flavor. It’s ideal for recipes that call for a hint of a rum taste, such as our favorite Cuban Pasta Salad.
To acquire a deeper taste than ordinary extracts, consider adding one tablespoon of the emulsion to your buttercream or baked products.
The emulsion is non-gluten and water-based, created in the United States. It arrives in a convenient free-of-BPA recycled PET plastic container, ideal for keeping any emulsion leftovers.
Overall, we suggest getting this product to anyone who enjoys rum-flavored baking! It’s also a terrific method to infuse your beverages with the rum flavor. Cheers!
Pros:
– Creates a rum taste in baked goods and beverages
– There is no alcohol involved, making it perfect for some people
– Ideal for any recipe that calls for a hint of rum flavor
Cons:
– Requires more than just one teaspoon to create deeper flavors
McCormick Rum Extract
- Bold rum flavor
- No corn syrup, non-GMO & gluten-free
- No artificial flavors or colors
- MOCKTAILS: Stir a few drops into frozen, blended piña coladas for a tasty mocktail
- SUBSTITUTION: ½ tsp. Extract = 1 tbsp. light rum; 1 ½ tsp = 1 tbsp. dark rum
McCormick Rum Extract is an item that will add a robust, rich rum taste to your favorite dish. It will also enhance the flavor of a martini or margarita. The extract is created with free-of-GMO cornstarch and natural sugar.
There are no synthetic flavors or colors in the extract, and it is free of gluten. This extract is ideal for rum beverages or mixed drinks prepared quickly.
McCormick is excellent at advising you on how much extract to use in place of mild, dark, and other rums.
The fact that it has no alcohol, which is great if you’re creating anything for a child, and it’s straightforward to use are two of my favorite features of this extract. You simply put a few drops to your dish or replace it for half of the rum asked for.
Overall, McCormick Rum Extract is a fantastic product that will bring your favorite dishes to life, and the company is a tremendous brand that produces high-quality goods.
Pros:
– GMO-free
– Gluten-free
– No artificial flavors or colors
Cons:
– Might not be as tasty as other extracts
Ossoro Baker’s Rum Pastry Flavour
- OSSORO BEST PRODUCT- Water-Based and Alcohol Free. Propylene Glycol, Natural Extracts, nature identical and natural ingredients. These Premium Flavours are made in small batches. Shelf Life: 24 months.
- PURE INGREDIENT- Premium Authentic Flavour 100% Vegetarian. Does not contain alcohol. It is very concentrated and generally requires less, per recipe. Use sparingly.
- VERSATILE USES- This flavor is full rich robust flavorings for enhancing flavors in food, baked goods, desserts and beverages. Be creative and experiment. Add to frostings, icings, fondants, cookies, cakes, cupcakes, donuts, muffins, pancakes, breads, desserts, ice cream, shakes, malts, protein shakes, smoothies and yogurt and even in culinary preparations.
- MIXING RATIOS & STRENGTH- Some flavors are more concentrated than others. You decide the ratio and how concentrated and strong the flavor will be. For best results follow the indicated dosage guidelines on the product label.
This is a taste that is both tasty and strong. It can be used in culinary and beverage dishes and as a flavor in other dishes. This flavor is delicious and contains a single vegetarian component.
It can also add flavor to baked items, sweets, and drinks. The taste concentration is determined by the customer’s preference for how weak or strong it should be. This flavor is adaptable and can be used in a variety of dishes.
Because its flavor is so potent, it usually necessitates fewer ingredients per dish. It also has a two-year shelf life so that you can preserve it for later! The easy-to-store packaging makes storing a breeze, and the container seals snugly to avoid spills.
The flavors are genuine, original, and vegetarian and are prepared in tiny amounts. This flavor is also free-of-alcohol and water-based.
Overall, this is a terrific option if you’re seeking a solid rum flavor! It’s something we’d highly recommend!
Pros:
– The flavor is intense and well-made.
– It has a water base, which means it can be used in various dishes.
– Long shelf life
– This product package seals tightly to avoid spills.
Cons:
– May be too intense for some people’s liking.
McCormick Culinary Imitation Rum Extract
- SUBTLE SUGARY NOTES AND AROMA: Imitation rum extract recreates the subtle sugary notes and aroma that you associate with rum; features a pleasant, orangey color that enhances all kinds of dishes with a lovely sweetness
- PREMIUM RUM SUBSTITUTE: Made using premium ingredients, this rum flavoring extract makes it easy to substitute 2 teaspoons of extract for 1 tablespoon of dark rum or 1 tablespoon of extract for 5 tablespoons of light rum
- MADE FOR CHEFS: Crafted with chefs in mind, each bottle comes ready to use and contains 16 fluid ounces, making it easy to flavor desserts, sauces and baked goods; dispense individual drops or larger amounts by unscrewing the top
- CONCENTRATED AND VERSATILE: Rum flavoring is perfect for all kinds of menu items that call for rum if the team in your commercial kitchen wants to use a concentrated ingredient that won't affect your dish's texture
- FEEL GOOD RUM FLAVORING: Kosher and gluten-free for a light rum flavor you can feel good about enjoying yourself or serving to your guests; delicious imitation flavors retained even after cooking at high temperatures
McCormick Culinary Imitation Rum Extract is an excellent method to give your food that signature rum taste instead of the real stuff.
It has a pale orange and a delightfully pleasant, complementing rum-resemble flavor and aroma. It’s also versatile, so you can use it for whatever you want!
McCormick Culinary Imitation Rum Extract has you prepared whether you’re searching for a component to produce a Caribbean-kind BBQ sauce or enhance your handmade ice cream.
It’s also Kosher-authorized so that you may use it in any kosher dish! This fake rum extraction is ideal for anyone who enjoys rum but not its high alcoholic content.
You should know that one tablespoon of black rum yields two teaspoons of rum extraction, while one tablespoon of light rum produces five tablespoons of rum extract.
Moreover, the 16 fl oz container of McCormick Culinary Imitation Rum Extract makes it simple to pour tiny drops or more significant amounts as required. It also features a flip lid, so there’s no need to remove the cover to put it in!
Overall, this rum extract is ideal for chefs searching for a high-quality alternative. And not just the chefs, it’s also for you!
Pros:
– Easy to add the taste of rum into any dish easily.
– Widely available in stores, making it convenient for you.
– Designed to be suitable with kosher dishes.
Cons:
– Prices can get expensive if not bought in bulk.
LorAnn Butter Rum SS Flavor
- Our Butter Rum Flavor is creamy smooth with a buttery richness and a hint of spice. Its caramel-like flavor compliments cakes and candies and is decadence you’ll crave.
- Our Butter Rum Flavor is creamy smooth with a buttery richness and a hint of spice. Its caramel-like flavor compliments cakes and candies and is decadence you’ll crave.
- A little goes a long way! LorAnn’s super strength flavors are three to four times the strength of typical baking extracts.
- When substituting super strength flavors for extracts, use ¼ to ½ teaspoon for 1 teaspoon of extract.
- Typical uses: hard candy, general candy making, cakes, cookies, frosting, ice cream and a wide variety of other baking and confectionery applications.
LorAnn’s Butter Rum SS Flavor piqued our interest as baking extract fans. This taste is described as “creamy silky with a buttery smoothness and a dash of spice” on the container. It has a caramel taste that goes well with desserts and candy.
We discovered that the Butter Rum SS Flavor was adaptable, working well with rigid and general candies, cakes, biscuits, icing, and ice creams. Butter Rum is Kosher-certified, non-gluten, and manufactured in the United States.
Therefore, the flavor was rich, and we’re craving it now. It’s ideal for infusing richness into tasty treats. You will not be dissatisfied! The only drawback is that a little makes a huge difference, so measure carefully!
Overall, LorAnn’s Butter Rum SS Flavor is a must-try for everyone who enjoys baking or confectionary. It’s a delicious, high-quality flavor that will take your creations to the next level.
Pros:
– Rich, buttery flavor
– Works well with many sweet treat types
– Kosher-certified
Cons:
– Requires exact usage amount
Watkins Rum Extract
- Perfect for baking, flavoring drinks and more
- Ingredients all naturally derived
- No Artificial Colors or Flavors
- Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Corn Syrup Free, Kosher
- Crafted in the USA
Watkins Rum Extract is a whole-natural, excellent-quality extract that’s great for baking and enhancing drinks.
Since 1869, the business has been creating extracts, with founder William Watkins creating the first rum extraction.
They now have more than 40 rum extract varieties to choose from, including classic caramel and chocolate varieties and more current ones like pia colada.
This extract is manufactured in limited quantities in the United States to provide excellent quality. The taste of the Watkins Rum Extract amazes us. It is tasty and rich without being overpowering.
It’d be ideal for baking or enhancing beverages. We also love that it is free-of-gluten, non-GMO, non-corn-syrup, and Kosher-authorized, so you can feel good about what you’re using in your kitchen.
It is a good choice for folks concerned about what gets into their food because the components are entirely organically-produced and include no artificial colors or tastes.
Overall, we would strongly advise anyone seeking an excellent-quality, whole-natural extraction to try Watkins Rum Extract.
Pros:
– Superior quality extract, made from natural ingredients.
– Tasty and rich without being overpowering.
– Non-GMO, kosher-approved.
Cons:
– None
OliveNation Butter Rum Flavoring
- OliveNation Butter Rum Flavoring, Buttered Rum Extract for Baking, Beverages, Sauces
- Tastes Like Classic Hot Buttered Rum
- Butter Rum Flavor can be used in cookies, cakes and icings
- PERFECT for Adding Rich Flavor to Hot or Cold Beverages, too!
- Sugar Free, Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Kosher, Vegan
This genuine butter rum extract will give your baked products the taste of buttery rum. The flavor is right on for those who enjoy a decent buttery rum. The best part is that it’s produced with organic taste, so you can confidently use it in your dishes.
Biscuits, pastries, and frostings are all examples of this. The ethanol and polyethylene glycol will boil in your hot drink and provide the wonderful buttery flavor you want.
That’s why many customers say this extraction is impressive, whether you’re seeking a sweet occasion for yourself or want to add a festive touch to your next event.
We are confident that it will give any baked dish a rich and buttered flavor. Because the extract is condensed, you won’t need much, and it’ll fit quickly in your cupboard.
It’s also simple to use; simply add it to your dish as recommended. Prepare to savor the flavor of buttery rum whenever you wish!
However, those who are allergic to alcohol or desire to eliminate it may find the components unappealing. This item is not suitable for gluten-sensitive people because it includes gluten as a component.
Those with allergies should avoid this combination because it may include almonds. Overall, if you want to add a buttery rum taste to your baked products, this is a terrific alternative.
Pros:
– It tastes buttery and rummy at the same time
– Has organic ingredients
– Fit in easily in your cupboard
Cons:
– Not suitable for gluten-sensitive people
Cook’s Choice Pure Rum Extract
- We've formulated this appealing flavor using Fine Meyer's Rum for the best rum flavor.
- 4oz. Resealable Amber Glass Bottle for Safe & Convenient Storage
- All Natural, Gluten-Free, Vegan & Kosher
- Available in a variety of sizes, from 2oz. to 32oz.
Cook’s Choice Pure Rum Extract is a simple flavoring extraction manufactured with premium Meyers rum for the most excellent rum taste possible.
This extract is made using Fine Meyer’s Rum, which offers a deep taste that many people enjoy. It’s also sugar-free and free of artificial additives, so it tastes fantastic instead of being sickeningly sweet like many other products on the market.
This extract is vegan, free-of-gluten, and Kosher-certified, making it a good option for many folks. The 4-ounce resealed amber glass bottle adds a beautiful flair to the package, keeping the food fresh and protected from light.
You may also acquire it in many quantities, which is convenient because you won’t have to purchase a large bottle that would be wasted when you or your friends don’t like the flavor.
Overall, Cook’s Choice Pure Rum Extract is an excellent choice for those looking for a rum flavor that packs a punch.
Pros:
– Deep flavor
– Sugar-free and all-natural ingredients
– Comes in a variety of sizes
– Convenient resealable amber glass bottle
Cons:
– Might be too intense for some people’s taste buds.
Spice Supreme Rum Flavor Extract
- Adds rich rum flavor to baked goods and frostings
- Used in restaurants and home gourmet cooking.
- Best Value
- OU Kosher Certified
Spice Supreme has been in business for more than 60 years. Its mission was always to supply the highest-quality ingredients and flavors at incomparable costs to its clients.
Spice Supreme sells its products in more than 20 countries and has diverse extracts, lubricants, spices, and dressings. What distinguishes Spice Supreme from other brands?
Spice Supreme Rum Flavor Extract is fantastic for baked products and icings. It’s ideal for infusing rum taste into sweets. The extract is the highest grade extraction on the marketplace because it has no artificial flavors or colors.
The extract is OU Kosher-guaranteed, kosher-approved, non-gluten, which indicates it was created in a plant that also makes milk products without any non-kosher components.
Overall, we highly recommend this product because of its high quality and affordable price! You won’t regret giving it a try!
Pros:
– High-quality extract
– Affordable
– Extracted from natural ingredients, no artificial flavors or colors
– No added sugar, perfect for those with dietary restrictions
Cons:
– None
DaVinci Gourmet Butter Rum Syrup
- DaVinci Sugar Free Butter Rum Syrup
- 1 - 25.4 oz bottle
- Sugar Free, Fat Free, Calories Free, Carbohydrate Free
- Creamy butter and sweet light rum inspired this nonalcoholic Sugar Free Butter Rum
- Packaging may vary
DaVinci Gourmet Butter Rum Syrup is the perfect way to add a little something extra to your latte, tea, or hot cocoa. It’s non-calorie, free-of-sugar, and fat-free!
As a result, DaVinci Gourmet Butter Rum Syrup is ideal for people searching for a sugar-free choice. It has a delectable taste that will enhance the flavor of any beverage and is perfect for gratifying any sweet craving.
This syrup is a great way to add spice to your morning cup of coffee or to have a soothing cup of cocoa in the evening. This syrup contains no artificial ingredients or aromas and is created with organic ingredients.
Although the packaging may change, this item will always be packaged in an amber glass container, ensuring that customers receive only the top-quality syrups on the market.
Today, try DaVinci Gourmet Butter Rum Syrup in your favorite beverages and enjoy the delicious flavor! This syrup has a lovely buttery taste with enough mild rum richness to make it appropriate for anytime
Pros:
– Sweet and buttery flavor
– Mild rum richness is perfect for any time of the day.
– Non-calorie, free of sugar, and fat-free
– Organic ingredients
Cons:
– Packaging may vary
Happy Home Imitation Rum Flavoring
- HAPPY HOME IMITATION CINNAMON FLAVORING - Imitation cinnamon flavor in 7 oz. bottle.
- FEATURES & BENEFITS - Happy Home Imitation Cinnamon flavoring is made with high-quality ingredients. Certified Kosher
- STAPLE INGREDIENT FOR COOKING AND BAKING - Enhance the taste of your food and baked goods with this imitation cinnamon flavoring. Commonly used as an affordable ingredient in desserts such as candies, muffins, doughnuts, pies, cakes, cupcakes, cookies, frosting, brownies, ice cream, custards, puddings, sauces or glazes.
- HIGH-QUALITY INGREDIENTS - We still use our original 1929 recipe for our imitation cinnamon flavoring. Contains proylene glycol, natural flavors, caramel color, and FD&C Yellow #6.
- MADE IN THE USA - Southern Flavoring Company, Inc., manufacturer of Happy Home Flavoring, is a small family company based in Virginia that has been committed to producing the most flavorful baking flavors and extracts for nearly 90 years.
For approximately 90 years, the Southern Flavoring Company has been dedicated to creating the most delicate delectable baking flavors and extraction.
Since 1929, this modest Virginia-based family business has supplied excellent-quality imitation rum flavor. Imitation rum flavoring from Happy Home is produced using excellent-quality components.
As a result, it is a common baking element that enriches delicacies such as chocolates, cupcakes, donuts, pies, desserts, icing, milkshakes, caramels, sauces, and enamels by infusing them with a unique taste that lingers in your mouth.
The artificial rum flavor has only one ingredient: propylene glycol, which provides sweetness and makes it water permeable. It also acts as a flavor transporter and food component solvent.
Pros:
– Excellent for baking and cooking
– Affordable price
– High-quality ingredients
– Consistently great flavor
– Convenient bottle for easy pouring
Cons:
– May need to add more than recommended
OliveNation Rum Baking Emulsion
- OliveNation Rum Baking Emulsion, Kosher, Gluten Free, Vegan Flavoring adds Real Rum Taste to Baked Goods & Recipes
- Water-Soluble Formulation Designed to Retain Flavor During Baking and Cooking
- Professional Quality Bakery Emulsion is Perfect for Use in Both Sweet and Savory Recipes
- GREAT SUBSTITUTE FOR EXTRACTS: 1 teaspoon extract is equal to 1 teaspoon emulsion
- Add Classic Rum Flavor to Specialty Diets: Gluten Free, Vegan, and Kosher Ingredient
For the majority of our life, we’ve been baking. Many baked items provide a sweet and salty combination that we enjoy—cakes with a deep, delicious flavor appeal to me.
Most rum cake traditional recipes contain rum extraction, but we’ve discovered that this component can occasionally leave too much alcohol left. OliveNation’s Rum Baking Emulsion offers us the delightful flavor of rum without the alcohol.
It’s also simple to use! You simply add it to your dish one tablespoon at a time, and you’re done! OliveNation has done an excellent job of creating a product that will provide you with all of the flavors you desire without the wine-related headaches!
Anyone who enjoys baked items with a rich, robust flavor should try this Rum Baking Emulsion. It’s ideal for cakes, enamels, and so much more!
Pros:
– No alcohol taste for people with sensitivities to it
– 100% natural flavor
– Easily integrates into recipes
Cons:
– Only available in small quantities
OliveNation Pure Rum Flavor
- OliveNation Rum Flavor, Extracted from Myer's White and Other Fine Rums, Clear Flavoring Extract for Baking
- Rum extract is used in baking and cooking recipes to give them true rum flavor and add deep, rich flavor note
- PERFECT FOR flavoring cakes, cookies, fillings, frostings, sauces, puddings, and more
- RUM FLAVORING FOR BEVERAGES: Add rum extract to hot or cold beverages; Perfect in eggnog, coffee, cocoa, smoothies
- Non-GMO, Certified Kosher, Vegan, and Gluten Free in a water soluble, clear formulation
OliveNation Pure Rum Flavor is a rum extraction created from the most excellent Jamaican rum free of alcohol. It can be used in cooking and baking preparations to offer an authentic rum taste without the typically high alcohol concentration.
This whole-natural extract is also available in various quantities, the smallest of which is 2 ounces. The company provides this product to make dishes and drinks taste as if they were prepared or blended with genuine rum without the risk of drunkenness.
Water, caramel color, and alcoholic components from Jamaican rum are among the ingredients, which offer the drink its original flavor while maintaining the alcohol content to nil!
This extract is ideal for seeking a great-tasting alternative to regular wines or liquor. Whether you’re baking a cake or mixing up a hurricane, OliveNation Pure Rum Flavor is the right choice for you.
Pros:
– Provides all-natural flavors
– Can be used for cooking and baking
– Available in various quantities
Cons:
– It might not work for tastings or cocktails
Organic Flavor Extract Rum Raisin
- FREE from ALL Peanut, Tree Nut, Soy. Gluten, Dairy, Eggs, Shellfish, Fish, GMO
- FREE from Monosodium Glutamate, Artificial Colors, AZO Dyes
- FREE from Oils that are Refined, Bleached or Deodorized
- Rum Raisin Organic Flavor Extract comes in a 2 ounce Amber Glass Bottle
- Nutrition Facts: Serving Size - 1 Drop Calories - 0, Total Fat - 0g, Saturated Fat - 0g, Cholesterol - 0mg, Sodium 0mg, Total Carbohydrate 0g, Dietary Fiber 0g, sugars 0g, Protein 0g, Vitamin a 0%, Vitamin C 0%, Calcium 0%, Iron 0%. *Percent Daily Values are be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.
Rum with Organic Flavor Extract Raisin is a diverse and delectable non-sugar extract that enhances the flavor of food and beverages. Baked items, sweets, milkshakes, drinks, and cooking specialties all benefit from it.
This extract was created using only the highest quality organic components to give you an unrivaled unique taste. The manufacturers use their experience to create vegan and non-gluten, making them suitable for any diet!
That implies you can use it in your favorite meals or as a decoration for your next meal without having to experiment with baking.
You can also use this excellent extract to sweeten your morning tea or coffee without the calories or discomfort caused by processed sweeteners like cane sugar, corn syrup, or rice syrup.
Organic Flavor Extract is a nutritious substitute for sugary beverages and high-carbohydrate dishes. This extract is also devoid of GMOs, vegan-friendly, and manufactured in the United States! Also, it arrives in a 2-ounce amber glass container.
Pros:
– Provides a natural and organic sugar alternative
– Suitable for any diet
– Enhances the flavor of food and beverages
– Sugar-free and vegan-approved
Cons:
– No nutritional information is available
Liquor Quik Extra Dark Jamaican Rum
- Dark jamaican rum essence - contains not alcohol
- 20 ml - made with natural extracts and essential oils
- Extra dark jamaican rum is a classic dark rum of the highest quality
- Item Product Dimension: 1.2" L x 1.2" W x 3.5" H
Liquor Quik Extra Dark Jamaican Rum is the highest quality dark rum. It contains no alcohol and comes in 20 ml bottles.
This product is made with natural extracts and essential oils, providing an authentic taste experience for your palate with every sip you take.
The Liquor Quik Extra Dark Jamaican Rum flavor profile includes vanilla, oak, caramel, fruits (peaches), cinnamon, and other detectable flavors on the nose and in the mouth when tasting this fine liquor.
As a result, it creates a dark rum drink without alcoholic content but with a strong aroma and flavor suitable for use in both alcoholic and non-alcoholic applications.
This fine dark rum is essential for making your signature cocktails at home, marinating meat and seafood dishes like our entire family’s recipe for baked beans and ham or beef roast glazed with my special BBQ sauce.
Pros:
– Comes in 20 ml bottles.
– Allows for an authentic taste experience for your palate with every sip you take.
– Various flavors
– Essential for your cooking
Cons:
– May be too intense of a flavor for some applications.
After reading our top 15 product reviews, have you found for yourself a perfect one? We are sure that most of the answers are no. You only see and read reviews about the products; however, you will know the fundamentals.
We agree with you on this one. Only when you know, the fundamentals will you likely gain new valuable knowledge about your future buying process.
And luckily, we have some valuable pieces of information that we want to share with you after hours of learning and researching. Firstly, let’s look at some basic information about the best dark rum for baking.
Basic Information About The Best Dark Rum For Baking
Rum extract is a flavoring agent used in a variety of food preparations. It is made from rum, sugar, and water. The alcohol is removed from the mixture through evaporation, leaving behind the flavorings. Rum extract can add a sweet or spicy flavor to dishes. It is also used as a preservative.
The extract also has many variants. Light rums are clear in color and dryer than heavy rums. Dark rums are typically aged for a long time because they are less refined and have more flavor.
The extract is available in both liquid and powdered form. It can be found in most supermarkets or grocery stores.
It is generally used in baking but can also be used in sauces, marinades, and dressings. It has a long shelf life and does not need to be refrigerated.
Rum extract is a convenient and economical substitute for an alcoholic drink. It does not take as much time to make rum and can be used in recipes that typically call for the drink.
Now, let’s see what benefits dark rum can bring you. We are confident that it will be a lot and you will be satisfied with this result.
Best Dark Rum For Baking Benefits
Rum extract is a great way to add depth and richness to desserts. It’s also very versatile in both savory dishes and sweet ones.
One of the best things about rum extract is that it doesn’t have any added sugar, making it an excellent choice for those watching their weight or diabetic patients looking for alternative sweeteners.
Rum extract isn’t just limited to baking either, since some people swear by adding it into drinks instead of liquor if they’re trying to avoid alcohol altogether.
Because of its rich flavor and low price tag, it makes an excellent choice when you’re making mixed drinks and cocktails.
And if you want to help give your party an extra kick, add some rum extract to the mix and watch things liven up!
Factors To Consider When Choosing Best Dark Rum For Baking
Baking with rum is a popular option. Whether you are looking to add a little flavor or for some liquid in your recipe, the best dark rum for baking will be sure to surprise you.
Dark rums can be used in any type of baked goods, but specific recipes call specifically for them, such as fruitcakes and gingerbread cakes. They can also be mixed with other liquids such as milk when making ice-creams or sauces.
However, how can you know what is the perfect option for you? Here are some of our suggestions
Country Of Origin
When looking for a good baking rum, the first thing to consider is the country of origin. Caribbean rums are generally made with sugar cane juice, while molasses is used in rums from other parts of the world. This results in different flavors and textures.
Recipe Types
The second consideration is what kind of recipe you are using, as some recipes call for white or brown sugar instead of regular granulated sugar.
If your recipe calls for white or brown sugar, you should use light-bodied rum with little to no flavor. On the other hand, if it uses only regular granulated sugar, you can use any dark rum that suits your taste preferences and budget.
Alcoholic Content
The third factor to consider is the alcohol by volume (ABV). You will want a rum with an ABV of at least 40% for baking. This will ensure that the ethanol in the rum reacts with the other ingredients in your recipe and produces a moist cake.
The higher percentage shows more alcoholic content and more robust flavor; however, this does not necessarily mean they will make a better choice.
Dark rums are not just for desserts! They can also make ice creams, sauces, and cocktails. The alcohol content in these other recipes is also essential, though, as it affects the taste and texture of the final product.
Richness
This factor indicates how strong or rich you want your baked goods to taste. The flavor from a higher quality rum will be more intense than a lower quality rum.
So, if you’re looking for a subtle flavor, then go for a lower-quality rum, but if you want something with a lot of kick, then go for a higher-quality rum.
Preference
Lastly, consider your personal preference. Do you want a basic dark rum for baking, or would you prefer one with additional flavors? Dark rums come with many different flavor profiles.
Some are spicy, some have a caramel taste, and others have a strong molasses flavor. There are also combination rums that have been blended with other flavors to produce rum cream or spiced rum.
The flavored types may be better for drinking, but the basic dark rums work just as well in baking as they do in drinks. Picking the right one for you will come down to personal preference.
Here is a helpful video for you:
FAQs about Best Dark Rum For Baking
– How do you know if your rum extract is bad before opening it and trying it so you can throw it away?
To test the quality of your rum extract, place a spoonful (or tablespoon) in half a cup of hot water. If there is an unpleasant odor or taste, the extract has gone wrong and should not be consumed.
– Does it matter what kind of sugar you use when cooking with dark rum?
It doesn’t matter what kind of sugar you use when cooking with dark rum; the type of sugar that will shine through is whatever type you use. You can use honey, agave nectar, brown sugar, or any other sweetener to get the job done.
– Why is brown sugar added to some rum recipes but not others?
Brown sugar is often added to rum, bourbon, or whiskey recipes because it’s sweeter than granulated sugar and cuts through the alcohol.
It also changes the color so you can pretend it’s more sophisticated than just using plain white sugar. Just another way of sweetening up an old-fashioned cocktail without adding extra calories!
Conclusion
Ultimately, the best dark rum for baking is one that tastes good. While you may be tempted to buy an inexpensive bottle of dark rum because it’s less expensive, don’t settle for a product with poor flavor just because it matches your budget.
| No | Name | Image | Best For | Rating | Details |
| 1 | LorAnn Rum Bakery Emulsion, 4 ounce bottle | | Best for deep rum taste | VIEW PRODUCT | |
| 2 | McCormick Rum Extract With Other Natural Flavors, 1 fl oz (Pack of 6) | | Best for using for children | VIEW PRODUCT | |
| 3 | Ossoro Baker's Rum Pastry Flavour with 100% Vegetarian (1 Oz) | Food Flavoring | No Sugar Added, Non-GMO, Gluten-Free Flavors | Used to Make Cakes, Snacks, Ice creams, Candies, Baking & More | | Best for adaptable flavor | VIEW PRODUCT | |
| 4 | McCormick Culinary Imitation Rum Extract, 16 fl oz - One 16 Fluid Ounce Bottle of Rum Extract for Baking, Best for Desserts, Fruit, Sauces and More | | Best for professional chefs | VIEW PRODUCT | |
| 5 | LorAnn Butter Rum SS Flavor, 1 ounce bottle | | Best for offering high-quality flavors | VIEW PRODUCT |
Instead, spend a little more money on high-quality ingredients and enjoy better-tasting drinks or desserts in return. By choosing a quality brand, you’ll ensure that your baked goods turn out delicious every time.
So, what is the best dark rum for baking? In short, it’s whichever one you enjoy the most! However, here is our top pick:
- Use LorAnn's Rum flavor Emulsion in any of your frostings and baked goods to impart the deliciously rich flavor of rum without all the alcohol. Use it anywhere you would a rum baking extract - and get more flavorful results!
- 1 teaspoon baking extract = 1 teaspoon emulsion
- Packaged in BPA free, recyclable PET plastic bottles.
- Water Based ( Soluble in Water)
- Gluten Free - Made in USA
Sadly, we’ve come to the end of the article! Thank you, and see you in our following reviews! Goodbye.